What a Missed Call Costs: Scenario Model by Industry 2026

SUMMARIZE WITH:
Author:
Chelsea Estrella
November 16, 2026
8 Mins

This report applies one transparent formula to four industries, using cited inputs where they exist and labelled scenario values where they do not, and shows the result as a low, base and high range instead of a single average.

Key findings

  • 3 of 11. Of the 11 pages we read for pricing and conversion inputs, only three state where their data came from and how many records it covers (Housecall Pro, MyCase and a 2017 DentistryIQ article on Sikka Software data).
  • $17 to $7,125. One missed new-prospect call is worth about $17 to $242 in plumbing, $128 to $618 in dental, $131 to $2,565 in law and $1,200 to $7,125 in HVAC replacement work, depending on the scenario.
  • 4.8x to 19.5x. Within each industry, the high scenario is 4.8 to 19.5 times the low one. Customer value and close rate drive this far more than the missed-call rate, whose whole published range moved one estimate by 1.8 times in our audit.
  • 14%. MyCase's 2023 data is the only conversion figure we found: 14% of law-firm leads attended a consultation, from 7% in personal injury to 27% in trust and estate. No page gave a call-to-booking rate for HVAC, plumbing or dental.
  • One contractor. The HVAC replacement average of about $11,500 comes from a single contractor's estimate quoted by ConsumerAffairs, not from a survey.

The model and how to read it

The expected value of one missed call is the share you would not win back, times your close rate, times what a customer is worth. Multiply by how many calls you miss to get revenue at risk.

EV = (1 āˆ’ r) Ɨ k Ɨ VĀ  Ā  Ā  Ā  L(year) = 12 Ɨ C Ɨ m Ɨ EV
Symbols used in the missed-call cost model
Symbol Meaning Where the values come from
V MeaningValue of a won customer (first job, case fee or first-year patient revenue) Where the values come fromCited pricing and fee sources, by industry
k MeaningClose rate: share of answered new-prospect calls that become customers Where the values come fromCited benchmarks where one exists; otherwise labelled as a scenario
r MeaningWin-back rate: share of missed callers you still win Where the values come fromOur assumption; no audited source measures it
m MeaningShare of new-prospect calls you miss Where the values come fromYour own phone logs; published ranges are in our Missed-Call Statistics Audit 2026
C MeaningNew-prospect calls per month Where the values come fromYour own phone logs
EV MeaningExpected value of one missed call Where the values come fromCalculated

Low, base and high. Each scenario fixes every input at once. The low scenario uses the smallest sourced V and k and a high win-back rate, so it gives the smallest loss. The high scenario uses the largest sourced V and k and a low win-back rate. The base scenario uses the midpoints. The three win-back rates (25%, 15% and 5%) are our assumptions, not measurements, and the report says so wherever they are used.

Sourced inputs by industry

We evaluated 11 sources for these inputs. Only three state where their data came from and how many records it covers; for law fees, close rates and win-back, no usable source exists, so those values are labelled scenarios.

Sourced inputs by industry, with low, base and high values and source quality
Input Low / base / high used What the source says Quality
HVAC replacement, value of a job (V) Low / base / high used$8,000 / $11,500 / $15,000 What the source saysConsumerAffairs (updated 20 May 2026): most homeowners pay $8,000 to $15,000, and the average is "around $11,500" according to one Tucson contractor. CBS News (27 May 2026) gives $5,000 to $28,000 with no source. QualityLowOne contractor's estimate, no method
Plumbing, value of a job (V) Low / base / high used$110 / $310 / $509 What the source saysHousecall Pro (updated 4 Nov 2026): "most small repairs between $110 and $509", from 2,473,496 service entries from its customers over 12 months to September 2026. Base is the midpoint, our arithmetic. QualityMediumMethod and size stated, but one vendor's customers and entries may exclude some charges
Dental, first-year value of a new patient (V) Low / base / high used$850 / $1,075 / $1,300 What the source saysDental Economics (15 Aug 2026): "approximately $850 to $1,300" from unnamed "conservative data"; the author works for a dental revenue-recovery vendor. Base is the midpoint, our arithmetic. QualityLowNo source named
Law, value of a client (V) Low / base / high used$2,500 / $5,000 / $10,000 What the source saysNo usable source found. The MyCase report gives no fees, and Clio's report page would not load. These are illustrative scenario values we chose. QualityNot sourced
Law, close rate (k) Low / base / high used7% / 14% / 27% What the source saysMyCase Benchmark Report 2024, Part 2: share of leads that attended a consultation in 2023, from 1,577,295 leads: personal injury 7%, all practice areas 14%, trust and estate 27%. We treat every consultation as a retained client, which overstates the true rate. QualityMediumFor what it measures; an upper-bound proxy for k
HVAC, plumbing, dental, close rate (k) Low / base / high used20% / 35% / 50% What the source saysNo source found. The only figures we saw were examples of 35% to 50% in two Signpost posts, which we treat as illustrative. Housecall Pro says only to track your own close rate. QualityNot sourcedScenario
Win-back rate (r) Low / base / high used25% / 15% / 5% What the source saysOur assumption. No page we read measured it. QualityNot sourcedScenario

The three pages that state a data source and size are Housecall Pro (2,473,496 entries), MyCase (1,577,295 leads) and a 2017 DentistryIQ article on Sikka Software data from more than 12,500 dental practices. That DentistryIQ figure (about $4,000 of gross production per new patient with a comprehensive exam, 2010 to 2016) measures something different from first-year value, so we did not use it.

Scenarios: what one missed call is worth

One missed new-prospect call is worth about $17 to $242 in plumbing, $128 to $618 in dental, $131 to $2,565 in law and $1,200 to $7,125 in HVAC replacement work, depending on the scenario. Each cell shows the arithmetic: (1 āˆ’ r) Ɨ k Ɨ V.

Expected value of one missed new-prospect call by industry, low, base and high scenarios, calculated as (1 āˆ’ r) Ɨ k Ɨ V
Industry Low scenario Base scenario High scenario
PlumbingSmall repairs Low scenario$16.500.75 Ɨ 20% Ɨ $110 Base scenario$92.230.85 Ɨ 35% Ɨ $310 High scenario$241.780.95 Ɨ 50% Ɨ $509
DentalNew patient, first year Low scenario$127.500.75 Ɨ 20% Ɨ $850 Base scenario$319.810.85 Ɨ 35% Ɨ $1,075 High scenario$617.500.95 Ɨ 50% Ɨ $1,300
LawClient Low scenario$131.250.75 Ɨ 7% Ɨ $2,500 Base scenario$5950.85 Ɨ 14% Ɨ $5,000 High scenario$2,5650.95 Ɨ 27% Ɨ $10,000
HVACReplacement job Low scenario$1,2000.75 Ɨ 20% Ɨ $8,000 Base scenario$3,4210.85 Ɨ 35% Ɨ $11,500 High scenario$7,1250.95 Ɨ 50% Ɨ $15,000

Three cautions apply to every row. The win-back rates (25%, 15%, 5%) and the 20% to 50% close rates for plumbing, dental and HVAC are scenario values, not sourced figures. The law values per client are illustrative and not sourced. And the HVAC row assumes every missed call was a replacement inquiry; repair and maintenance calls are worth much less, and we found no cited figure for them.

What ten missed calls cost

Ten missed new-prospect calls put between $165 and $71,250 of expected revenue at risk, depending on the industry and scenario. We use ten calls rather than a monthly or yearly total because no source we read gives a typical call volume or missed-call count for these industries.

Expected revenue at risk from ten missed new-prospect calls, by industry and scenario
Ten missed calls Low Base High
PlumbingSmall repairs Low$165 Base$922 High$2,418
DentalNew patient, first year Low$1,275 Base$3,198 High$6,175
LawClient Low$1,313 Base$5,950 High$25,650
HVACReplacement job Low$12,000 Base$34,213 High$71,250

To scale this to a year, count your own missed new-prospect calls in a typical month, multiply by 12, divide by 10, and multiply by the figure in the table. Values are rounded to the nearest dollar from the unrounded calculations.

What moves the number most

In every industry, the gap between the low and high scenario is 4.8 to 19.5 times, and most of it comes from customer value and close rate, not from how many calls you miss. For comparison, the entire published range of missed-call rates (22% to 40%) moved the law-firm estimate in our Missed-Call Statistics Audit 2026 by only 1.8 times.

How much each input widens the gap between the high and low scenario, by industry
Industry Customer value (V)high / low Close rate (k)high / low Win-back (1 āˆ’ r)high / low All three together
Plumbing Customer value (V)4.6x Close rate (k)2.5x Win-back (1 āˆ’ r)1.3x All three together14.7x
Dental Customer value (V)1.5x Close rate (k)2.5x Win-back (1 āˆ’ r)1.3x All three together4.8x
Law Customer value (V)4.0x Close rate (k)3.9x Win-back (1 āˆ’ r)1.3x All three together19.5x
HVAC Customer value (V)1.9x Close rate (k)2.5x Win-back (1 āˆ’ r)1.3x All three together5.9x

The lesson for a reader is practical: before comparing any published "cost of a missed call", ask what customer value and close rate it assumed. Two sources that disagree by a factor of ten may simply be using different customers, not measuring different things. The law spreads rest partly on our illustrative values, so treat that row as a demonstration of the method.

Estimate your own number in five steps

Your own phone and sales records beat any published average, and you can do this in an afternoon.

  1. Count your calls. Pull 30 to 90 days of call logs. Count new-prospect calls (C) and how many went unanswered (m). Leave out existing customers, vendors and spam.
  2. Set the value of a customer (V). Take the average revenue from new customers you won over the last 12 months: first job, first case fee or first-year patient revenue. Use revenue or gross profit, and say which.
  3. Set your close rate (k). Divide new customers won by answered new-prospect calls over the same period.
  4. Estimate win-back (r). For a month, log every missed caller you called back and how many became customers. If you cannot, run the calculation at 5%, 15% and 25%.
  5. Calculate and range it. Work out EV = (1 āˆ’ r) Ɨ k Ɨ V, then 12 Ɨ C Ɨ m Ɨ EV for the year. Re-run it with the least certain input at both ends, and report the range.

Limitations and method

How inputs were chosen. On 12 November 2026 we searched the web for pricing and conversion figures in four industries and opened the pages that looked most credible and recent. The selection is ours, not random, and not exhaustive. The page text was read by an AI research assistant, so re-check any figure on the live page before you cite it.

Pages we could not use. A Money article on HVAC prices could only be partly verified, so we did not use it. MyCase's report states no publication date; we infer September 2024 from its web address, and its lead data covers 2023.

What the numbers are.

  • Scenario values, not measurements: the win-back rates, the 20% to 50% close rates for plumbing, dental and HVAC, and the law value per client.
  • Revenue, not profit, and first job or first year only. Lifetime value is not counted, which understates what a customer is worth over time.
  • One job type per industry: small plumbing repairs, new-patient dental work, a law client, and an HVAC replacement. Mixed call types would lower the HVAC figures in particular.
  • The ten-call table is a way to compare scenarios. It is not a forecast for any business.

Corrections. If a source publishes a method we missed, or a figure changes, we will update the report, mark the date and say what changed.

Report version history
Version Date Change
1.0 First publication

Disclosure. aianswering.ai sells AI answering services, so we benefit if missed calls are taken seriously. We show every input and where it came from so you can check our work.

Sources

Pages opened and read on 12 November 2026. Dates are those shown on each page.

Used for model inputs

Used as cross-checks

ā€

Ready to See What AI Answering Can Do for Your Business?

Start a 1-month free trial and test AI Answering with your own calls. We configure the platform around your business's actual call workflow before you go live.